Pine Island Tap House
Pine Island, New York, USA · Est. 2023
Tally's Take
Why this matters
Pass 107 statewide rerank: missing ACTIVE production brewery recovered. Avoid confusion with the older, closed Pine Island Brewing Company; current tap house states on-site farm-brewery production and new ownership in March 2026. Licence class: New York State farm brewery / tap house. Orange County. Relocation: Converted former Pine Island firehouse; tap house dates to 2016, on-site brewing partnership/operation began in 2023, and ownership changed in March 2026.. Status as recorded: ACTIVE.
Travel Guide
Plan a visit
Drinking Pine Island Tap House? Stamp it in your passport.
Discover it here — collect it in the Passport. Track every beer, earn stamps, and build your own beer passport.
Every brewery deserves its full story told.
If you're the owner or team behind Pine Island Tap House, we'll build out your complete profile — history, the people, every beer — and feature you in a Tally's documentary. No cost, just your story.