Archive record · Brewery
Shelter Island Craft Brewery
Shelter Island, New York, New York, USA
- Founded
- 2015
- Archive ID
- TB-EW5XZW3X
- Last checked
- Not yet checked
Who owns this brewery?
The archive is still digging. That is a gap in the research, not a finding of independence.
Know who owns it? Tell us, and we will correct the record.
From the record
Summary
Official taproom verifies active location/current menu. Shelter Island Reporter documents owner James Hull and opening July 3, 2015 after state/federal approvals; 2018 profile independently repeats owner/brewer and opening date, half-barrel scale and island-grown ingredients. Licence class: Farm Brewer. Suffolk County. Owner as recorded: James Hull. Status as recorded: ACTIVE.
A summary written during research. The sourced facts are in the sections below.
Where it is
41.07147, -72.33920
Supplied by the research pass; method not recorded
Open on a mapThe People
Behind the beer
The Beer Library
Beers
114 IPA
Year-RoundAmerican IPA
Official current taproom menu: 114 IPA, East Coast style, subtle tangerine. Prior verified catalogue supplies 6.5% ABV; official menu upgrades identity/current status to A. (CURRENT ON TAP) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Nude Beach
RetiredFruit Beer
Official/verified brewery community catalogue verifies identity/style/ABV. Retained at B because stronger first-party product/menu page not located; availability not inferred. (HISTORICAL/RECENT CATALOGUE) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Liquid Sunshine
RetiredAmerican Pale Wheat
Official/verified brewery community catalogue verifies identity/style/ABV. Retained at B because stronger first-party product/menu page not located; availability not inferred. (HISTORICAL/RECENT CATALOGUE) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Dune Cottage
RetiredSaison
Official/verified brewery community catalogue verifies identity/style/ABV. Retained at B because stronger first-party product/menu page not located; availability not inferred. (HISTORICAL/RECENT CATALOGUE) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Üflaffen
RetiredImperial / Double IPA
Official/verified brewery community catalogue verifies identity/style/ABV. Retained at B because stronger first-party product/menu page not located; availability not inferred. (HISTORICAL/RECENT CATALOGUE) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Peach Beach Summer Ale
Year-RoundSummer Ale
Official current taproom menu verifies exact beer name and description: peachy, light. Numeric ABV/IBU not shown, so UNKNOWN. (CURRENT ON TAP) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Pilzn
Year-RoundPilsner
Official current taproom menu verifies exact beer name and description: gold, crisp, hoppy. Numeric ABV/IBU not shown, so UNKNOWN. (CURRENT ON TAP) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Honey Brown Ale
Year-RoundBrown Ale
Official current taproom menu verifies exact beer name and description: honey, rich, creamy. Numeric ABV/IBU not shown, so UNKNOWN. (CURRENT ON TAP) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Montezuma
RetiredMilk / Sweet Stout
2023 Southforker independently reports a Shelter Island chocolate stout; verified brewery catalogue identifies Montezuma as Milk/Sweet Stout 8.8%. Exact mapping is strongly supported but not first-party. (HISTORICAL) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Me So Hoppy
RetiredImperial / Double IPA
Verified brewery catalogue identity/style/ABV; 2019 check-ins at brewery corroborate historical service. No first-party archived product page located. (HISTORICAL) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Ferry & Seaplane
RetiredSession IPA
Verified brewery catalogue identity/style/ABV. Added as B-grade historical identity; no current status inferred. (HISTORICAL) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Castagna
RetiredPorter
Verified brewery catalogue identity/style/ABV; historical candidate from opening-era catalogue. (HISTORICAL) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →French Kiss
RetiredMilk / Sweet Stout
Verified brewery catalogue identity/style/ABV; historical identity only. (HISTORICAL) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Strike Zone
RetiredBlonde / Golden Ale - American
Verified brewery catalogue identifies a light spring ale with apricot; brewery-location activity in 2024-25 and external venue activity in 2026. ABV/IBU remain UNKNOWN. (RECENT/HISTORICAL) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →CTZ
RetiredAmerican IPA
Verified brewery catalogue identifies CTZ as American IPA; brewery-location activity documented 2018-19. ABV/IBU remain UNKNOWN. (HISTORICAL) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →FOG
RetiredImperial / Double IPA
Verified brewery catalogue identifies FOG as Imperial/Double IPA, 8.5%; brewery-location activity documented 2021-22. No current status inferred. (HISTORICAL) [New York Pass 140]
Drank this? Add it to your passport →Travel Guide
Plan a visit
Drinking Shelter Island Craft Brewery? Stamp it in your passport.
Discover it here — collect it in the Passport. Track every beer, earn stamps, and build your own beer passport.
Every brewery deserves its full story told.
If you're the owner or team behind Shelter Island Craft Brewery, we'll build out your complete profile — history, the people, every beer — and feature you in a Tally's documentary. No cost, just your story.
No payment affects this record — editorial policy